News & Information

Alleged Concerns with Trusts and Solutions

Tuesday 13, April 2010

Irrevocability
It is not correct that a trust cannot be revoked. Trusts can be made revocable, but this usually has tax, estate duty, asset protection and stamp duty disadvantages. Revocability should be discussed when the terms of the trust are being considered.

Loss of Control of Property
There are many people who like the idea of a trust but want to continue to exercise effective control over the trust assets, despite the transfer to the Trustees. If too much control is retained, however, the person who set up the trust (the Settlor) may be regarded by law as the owner. This may make the trust invalid. The following are devices that may reassure the Settlor about the concept of a trust and the transfer of assets:

  • Memorandum of Wishes
    It is common for the wishes of the Settlor to be noted in a written memorandum. This outlines how the assets would have been managed had the Settlor retained ownership. The wishes of the Settlor are not binding, but in practice reputable Trustees would follow them unless a change of circumstances makes it disadvantageous to the beneficiaries to act in that way.
  • Protector
    When setting up a trust it is possible to appoint a protector who has some degree of control over the trust property. We recommend limiting the protector’s powers to vetoing the decisions or actions of the Trustees, rather than having power to force the Trustees to act in a particular way as it is important to avoid the protector being considered a quasi-Trustee and possibly causing tax disadvantages.
    It is usual for a trusted friend, relative or professional adviser of the Settlor to beappointed protector. It is also becoming increasingly common to use the services of a professional trust company.
  • Company with Trust Structure
    Greater flexibility can be achieved by having the underlying assets owned by a company whose shares are owned by a trust. The Settlor may act as the director of the company and therefore exercise day-to-day control over the underlying assets with minimal need to refer to the Trustees.
    This two-tier structure may have tax and other disadvantages where the director of the company is resident in a high tax country but can be used to good effect in certain jurisdictions.
  • Joint Trustees
    A trust could be structured so that there are joint Trustees, with the agreement of both needed in order to take any action. The second trustee could be the Settlor or a corporation controlled by the Settlor. There may be negative tax or other consequences resulting from such a structure if the Settlor is resident in a high tax jurisdiction but this may be a solution worth considering.


Costs

Many people believe that the cost of running a trust is prohibitive. But the level of fees charged by independent trust companies generally makes the advantages of setting up a trust available to those with even relatively modest estates. Non-institutional trust companies offer a more personalised service and our clients also benefit from the fact that we are truly independent.

Inner Contact Us

The Hong Kong Trust Company LimitedSuite 5502, 55th Floor, Central Plaza, 18 Harbour Road Wanchai, Hong Kong

Phone: +852 37469080 Fax: +852 37469081

Email a Friend Print This Page